Login or Register

Recent Book Reviews

City of Bones
User rating
 
4.0
By Thea
"I first read this book when I was around 12 or 13. I was totally in love with this book—I read th..."
Googlies Funny Farm
Editor rating
 
7.0
By Mamma B
"Googlies is a series by Joanna Bicknell that includes several different titles. My daughter got t..."
Charlie the Ranch Dog
Editor rating
 
9.0
By Mamma B
"Charlie the Ranch Dog is a children's book by Ree Drummond, who is better known to most as The Pi..."
Land of Mountains
Editor rating
 
9.0
By Mamma B
"Land of Mountains by Jinx Schwartz was a fantastic book. But I have to say, that had I seen this ..."
If Babies Went To School
Editor rating
 
6.0
By Mamma B
"If Babies Went To School by Barbara Lock is a book mainly for grade school children to start dedu..."
The Hiccupotamus
User rating
 
9.3
By Susie Marcks
"Super cute! Definitely a parent to child reading book as they are all mixed up made up words that..."

Additional Information



Whoever You Are Hot

Whoever You Are

Book Info

Author Mem Fox
Illustrator Leslie Staub
Publisher Red Wagon Books, 1997
Genres Basic ConceptsEmotions / FeelingsFamily & FriendsHistory / Non-FictionLessons / BehaviorParenting Resources
Age Range InfantToddlerPreschoolK through 2nd

Children all over the world may be different in some ways. But inside, they are just like you.

Whoever You Are
8 out of 10 based on 1 reviews.

Mamma Bookworm review

Good Story, odd illustrations

0 of 0 people found the following review helpful
Whoever You Are by Mem Fox is a great book on showing young children the diversity in the world. It's a short book made for kids under approximately 7, so it's not too long or overly complicated. It shows examples of different houses, schools, foods and such, and how even though these may be different then what your family experiences, you still have several things in common like, joy, pain, love and kindness.

I really like the story and it doesn't go past the comprehension level of small children, however I find the illustrations kind of weird. Maybe they are considered avaunt guard - but I just find them disproportionate and honestly, a little freaky. I will admit that they are definitely their own style and are very colorful.

As much as I hate to admit it, there may be some parents out there that find the illustrations objectionable. I didn't care for the drawing style - but that is just my personal taste. The things that very few people might find objectionable would be possible references to other religions via the images. While I DO NOT feel this is a good reason to not purchase this book - I like to include ANYTHING that someone might be uncomfortable with in my reviews. I do feel it is important to note that religion is not mentioned in the text of the story.
Overall rating: 
 
7.8
Story:
 
9.0
Illustration:
 
6.0
Overall Opinion:
 
8.0
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes No
Reviewed by Mamma B
July 06, 2010
#1 Reviewer
View all my reviews
Report this review
 
Last updated: July 06, 2010
 
 

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this listing.

To write a review please register or login.